Skip to content
FX Sharp
Comdirect logo

Comdirect Review · 2026

Licensed · BaFin Broker

Review · 2026 Quickborn, Germany · Founded 1994 · Operating as Commerzbank Aktiengesellschaft

License verified 11 Nov 2026 Next re-scan Feb 2027 32+ years in operation Min. deposit €0 · Leverage 1:5 / 1:30

Key facts

Checked against BaFin register
Regulation
BaFin
Headquarters
Quickborn
Business model
Multi-Asset
Registration
Germany
Min. deposit
€0
Max leverage
1:5 / 1:30
Spread from
—
Founded
1994
Legal entity
Commerzbank Aktiengesellschaft
Website
comdirect.de
Support email
info@comdirect.de
Phone
+49 4106 708 2500
Influence index
D · Germany

Active licenses

Checked on the regulator's public register, not the broker's website.

1 active
  • BaFin DE
    Active
    Entity
    Commerzbank Aktiengesellschaft
    License ID
    BAK Nr. 100005
    Type
    Credit Institution
    Checked
    11 Nov 2026
    Tier
    Tier 1 Full investor protection

Score breakdown

Six dimensions, weighted per the published rubric.

Methodology →
Regulation 3.0/10
Weight 25%
License 2.5/10
Weight 20%
Risk Control 8.0/10
Weight 20%
Business 10.0/10
Weight 15%
Software 4.5/10
Weight 10%
Influence 2.0/10
Weight 10%

Strengths

6
  • BaFin-regulated through Commerzbank AG
  • No minimum deposit for CFD trading
  • CFD losses are limited to the available CFD account balance
  • German deposit protection explicitly covers CFD account balances
  • Unlimited CFD demo account with reset support
  • REST API supports brokerage orders and account access

Weaknesses

5
  • No MT4, MT5, or cTrader support
  • User aggregate is 1.4/5 from 4,160 reviews (scan 2026-09-21)
  • Commerzbank paid a €1.45m BaFin AML fine in 2024
  • Forex access is through CFDs, not spot forex
  • Mobile app language support is limited to German

Fees & trading

Min. deposit €0 · Leverage 1:5 / 1:30

Trading platforms

  • CFD Trader
  • CFD App
  • ProTrader

Account types

  • CFD Trader Account
  • CFD Basic Account
  • CFD Demo

Deposit methods

  • Bank Transfer
Full review 7 min read Updated 11 Nov 2026

Comdirect review 2026: German direct broker with forex CFDs, securities, banking, and proprietary platforms

Comdirect is a Quickborn-based multi-asset forex and securities broker founded in 1994. Licensed by BaFin under BAK number 100005 and supervised by the ECB, it trades forex CFDs on CFD Trader and CFD App with CFD Trader and CFD Basic accounts. Serves retail clients across currency, index, commodity, precious-metal, share, and index-futures CFDs, plus broader securities products.

What is Comdirect?

Comdirect is a German digital banking and brokerage brand with roots in 1994. The business was founded as a Commerzbank subsidiary and remains centered in Quickborn, Germany. Commerzbank completed the legal merger of the former comdirect Bank AG into Commerzbank AG on 2 November 2020. The brand now operates as part of Commerzbank AG rather than as a separately listed bank.

The product range combines banking, securities brokerage, and leveraged derivatives under one retail-facing brand. For forex-curious clients, the relevant product is a CFD (Contract for Difference), a derivative that tracks an underlying market without transferring ownership. Currency CFDs sit beside indices, commodities, precious metals, shares, and index futures. Société Générale acts as the market maker, meaning the firm providing bid and ask prices, for the CFD Trader environment.

Which regulators license Comdirect?

Comdirect operates through the regulated entity Commerzbank Aktiengesellschaft. BaFin (German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority) lists Commerzbank under license or registration number BAK Nr. 100005. The official comdirect imprint also identifies BaFin and the ECB (European Central Bank) as supervisory authorities. The current authorization was verified against Commerzbank's regulatory self-classification during the 21 September 2026 review scan.

German banking supervision also matters for customer cash protection. Comdirect states that eligible deposits receive statutory protection up to €100,000 per person through Germany's deposit guarantee framework. Its deposit-protection page explicitly includes CFD account balances among covered account types. Securities held in custody are treated differently because clients retain ownership of those securities.

Regulation does not erase the parent bank's enforcement history. BaFin announced fines totaling €1.45 million against Commerzbank AG on 22 April 2024. The notice covered supervisory failures involving Commerzbank and the former comdirect Bank AG (source: BaFin, 22 April 2024). The notice described late or insufficient customer-data updates and inadequate safeguards. This was an enforcement action, not a withdrawal of the bank's authorization.

Trading platforms

Trading platforms use proprietary comdirect interfaces rather than MetaTrader or cTrader. That distinction matters for traders who rely on platform-specific automation, plugins, or third-party signals. FXSharp found no verified MT4 or MT5 server. The main interfaces are CFD Trader, CFD App, and ProTrader.

CFD Trader

CFD Trader is the dedicated browser-based derivatives platform for live CFD accounts. It supports order placement, amendment, cancellation, account-value monitoring, chart analysis, and direct chart trading. The official platform documentation also allows multiple layouts and watchlists. Live positions and account metrics update inside the trading interface.

CFD App

CFD App provides native access on Apple and Android devices. The official CFD FAQ confirms trading through iPhone, Android smartphones, iOS tablets, and Android tablets. Mobile users access the same CFD product family rather than a separate account structure. The platform remains focused on the broker's proprietary workflow.

ProTrader

ProTrader is a browser-based real-time information and trading platform for the broader securities account. It includes watchlists, charts, news, alerts, depot views, and an order book. The basic real-time package is offered without a recurring platform charge. It is separate from the dedicated CFD Trader workflow.

Account types

Account types include two principal live CFD models plus a demo environment. The models change required capital per position rather than the underlying product menu. Clients can hold up to three CFD accounts per account connection according to the official account documentation. Switching the live account model requires closing open positions and cancelling open orders first.

  • CFD-Trader Account: live account with intraday leverage up to 1:30.
  • CFD-Basic Account: live account using a uniform 1:5 leverage model.
  • CFD Demo: unlimited practice access with virtual capital and reset functionality.

What is the minimum deposit?

The minimum deposit for CFD trading is €0. Comdirect's official CFD conditions also state that there is no minimum capitalization requirement for using CFD Trader. This removes a fixed funding threshold but does not remove position-level capital requirements. Each trade still requires enough available account equity for the applicable exposure.

Deposit and withdrawal methods

Deposit and withdrawal methods center on bank transfer. Existing customers can transfer money from their comdirect settlement account into the CFD subaccount, where internal transfers can arrive within minutes. The official onboarding page says direct transfers from another bank to the CFD account normally take at least one day longer. FXSharp could not verify a card, e-wallet, or crypto funding method.

Tradeable instruments

Tradeable instruments exceed 1,200 CFDs according to the broker's trading-platform documentation. Available categories include shares, equity indices, precious metals, currency pairs, commodities, volatility indices, and interest-rate futures. The current commercial page separately states that more than 1,000 share and index-futures CFDs are available. Forex exposure is delivered through currency CFDs rather than spot-forex ownership.

Instrument coverage is account-linked, so pricing and capital requirements can vary by underlying market. The live platform displays instrument details such as trading hours, fees, and reference markets. This is useful because a single headline spread does not describe the full CFD range. FXSharp therefore lists the starting spread as N/A rather than inventing a universal pip figure.

Spread and commission structure

Spread and commission costs vary by instrument. A spread is the gap between a market's bid and ask price. Comdirect does not publish one verified universal "from" spread across its forex CFD range. The official fee page lists €0 order commission for indices, currencies, precious metals, and commodities. Normal market spreads and product costs still apply.

Some CFD categories add explicit transaction commissions. Share CFDs carry 0.10% commission, subject to a 4.90 euro minimum and 59.90 euro maximum. Index-futures CFDs also have percentage commissions with minimum and maximum charges. Overnight positions can create additional financing adjustments based on contract value and the relevant rate formula.

Leverage and margin requirements

Leverage and margin requirements differ between the two live account models. Margin is the capital set aside to support a leveraged position. The CFD-Basic Account uses a 20% margin requirement, which corresponds to 1:5 leverage. The CFD-Trader Account starts from a 3% intraday margin on applicable instruments, corresponding to leverage up to 1:30. Actual requirements remain instrument-specific inside the trading platform.

Leverage increases market exposure relative to deposited capital, so losses can develop faster than on an unleveraged position. Comdirect states that losses on both live CFD models are limited to the available balance in the CFD account. Its current risk warning says 77.1% of retail CFD accounts lose money with this provider. The firm also states that no legal entitlement to a margin call or automatic position closure exists.

How does customer support work?

Customer support is primarily German-language service tied to the domestic banking operation. The general contact page lists telephone support at +49 4106 708 2500 and a contact-form route. The dedicated CFD team publishes service hours from Monday through Sunday, with longer weekday coverage. The contractual language for the CFD relationship is German.

User feedback presents a separate signal from regulatory status. FXSharp's prior check recorded a user-aggregate rating of 1.4/5 from 4,160 reviews on 21 September 2026. An aggregate rating summarizes user sentiment but does not prove a specific operational failure. Regulatory authorization and customer-review sentiment therefore answer different questions.

Demo account and onboarding flow

Demo account access is free and has no stated time limit. New demo users receive access to both CFD-Trader and CFD-Basic practice models with virtual starting capital. The official documentation says the demo can be reset repeatedly. A free "Meine comdirect" registration is required, but an existing funded brokerage relationship is not.

Live onboarding differs for existing customers and newcomers. Existing comdirect customers can open the CFD subaccount using their established authentication process. The broker states that live trading can normally begin by the next banking day after setup. The demo remains separate from any requirement to deposit real capital.

FeatureComdirect Information
Founded1994
HeadquartersQuickborn, Germany
Disclosed regulatorsBaFin, BAK Nr. 100005; ECB supervision
Registration verifiedYes, Commerzbank AG authorization verified on 21 September 2026
Trading platformsCFD Trader, CFD App, ProTrader
Minimum deposit€0
Maximum leverage1:30 live CFD-Trader Account; 1:5 CFD-Basic Account
Account typesCFD-Trader Account, CFD-Basic Account, CFD Demo
Islamic accountNot disclosed on official site
Customer supportGerman-language support; dedicated CFD team
Deposit methodsBank Transfer

Comdirect verdict: pros, cons, and the catch

The broker combines German banking supervision, a long operating history, and proprietary CFD technology inside the Commerzbank group. The €0 minimum deposit, two live leverage models, and unlimited demo reduce account-entry friction. Deposit protection explicitly includes CFD account cash, while CFD losses are limited to the available CFD balance. These protections do not remove market losses from leveraged trading.

The main trade-offs are platform choice, pricing format, and user sentiment. MT4, MT5, and cTrader are not supported, and there is no universal starting spread to compare across currency CFDs. The 2024 BaFin fine remains part of the parent bank's recent enforcement record, while the user aggregate sits at 1.4/5. Forex exposure is available through CFDs, not spot forex.

Forex and derivative products carry high leverage; some or all invested capital may be lost. This content is for information only, not investment advice. Verify the broker's current regulation status with the relevant authority's official site before any investment decision.

FXSharp Editorial Team

FXSharp is an independent site that reviews forex brokers and prop trading firms. Every license is checked on the regulator's own register, every score follows our published methodology, and no broker can pay for a higher rating.

Published 11 Nov 2026 · Last verified 11 Nov 2026 · Sources: BaFin register, comdirect.de

Frequently asked questions

Comdirect is operated by Commerzbank AG under German banking supervision. BaFin, the German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority, lists Commerzbank under BAK Nr. 100005, while the comdirect imprint also identifies the European Central Bank as a supervisory authority. The authorization was verified during the 21 September 2026 review scan.
Comdirect's minimum deposit for its CFD accounts is €0. The broker's official CFD conditions also state that there is no minimum capitalization requirement to use CFD Trader. Traders still need enough available account equity to meet the margin requirement for each position, so a zero account minimum does not mean positions can be opened without capital.
Comdirect supports proprietary trading platforms rather than MT4, MT5, or cTrader. Its CFD clients use CFD Trader and the CFD App, while ProTrader serves the broader securities account. The CFD App supports Apple and Android devices, and CFD Trader includes chart trading, order management, watchlists, and live account-value monitoring.
Comdirect uses bank transfer as the verified CFD funding method. Existing customers can move funds from a comdirect settlement account into the CFD subaccount, with internal transfers potentially arriving within minutes. The broker states that direct transfers from another bank to the CFD account normally take at least one day longer.
Comdirect prices CFD trading by instrument rather than publishing one universal starting spread. Its official fee page lists €0 order commission for indices, currencies, precious metals, and commodities, while market spreads and product costs still apply. Share CFDs and index-futures CFDs can carry additional percentage commissions, and overnight positions can generate financing adjustments.

User reviews & complaints

Verified client reviews only. Complaints are forwarded to the broker.

Had a problem with Comdirect? Let's get it solved.

Our editors check your complaint and send it to Comdirect. The broker answers you here, in public.

File a complaint
  1. 1 You describe the problem
  2. 2 We check it and send it to Comdirect
  3. 3 Comdirect replies here, in public
Your rating
Proof of account *

Published as a verified client review once an editor has checked your proof.

No reviews yet
Traded with Comdirect? Your experience helps others make a decision.

Complaints (0)

No complaints filed yet. File a complaint →

Is this your company?

Claim the Comdirect profile to reply to complaints and reviews in public, keep these facts current and show a live rating badge on your website. It is free.

Claim this profile →
Comdirect website screenshot

Quick sign-in

Sign in with your Google account in seconds

An account is created automatically if you do not have one